Public Health Study Finds Criminal Deterrence is Effective

October 6th, 2008  |  Published by BRAHA Editor in Drug Law


Print This Post  |  Email This Post

Professor J.P. Shepherd of the Violence Research Group at the University of Wales in the UK, published the results of his study “Criminal deterrence as a public health strategy” in the November 17, 2001 issue of The Lancet.

The study looked at individuals who commit violence or endanger others while under the influence of alcohol. Shepherd states that “Deterrence in this context is the successful persuasion of offenders and potential offenders, through knowledge of criminal risks, not to injure others.” He notes that “Strong evidence suggests that random blood-alcohol tests deter offenders, and that administrative laws per se (automatic penalties) are more effective than criminal sanctions….Overall, ‘there is considerable evidence that increasing the actual certainty of punishment for drunk driving in ways that also ensure adequate publicity can effect reductions in drunk driving.’”

In conclusion Shepherd writes “For health-policy makers, coming to terms with the importance of deterrence alongside preschool education and early family support is an essential prerequisite to forging partnerships between criminal justice systems and health services to achieve communities that are both safe and just.”

There are several important aspects to the study, however the most important is scientific documentation that “knowing” there will be a punishment is, in itself, a deterrent to crime. This same reasoning obviously supports imposing meaningful sanctions on those who use illicit drugs, many of whom commit acts of crime and violence while under the influence, and is an argument against legalization and in support of random drug-testing as well.

 

Source: Northwest Center for Health & Safety


Print This Post  |  Email This Post

ATTENTION: The publication of the material in this site is intended as a source for research and consulting by serving as a source of information for society and therefore has no commercial objectives.


Medicine & Health »

  • Liquid Candy - The new addiction is taxing addictions
    Oct 7, 2009 | Full text

    The world’s best business model has always been addiction. Tobacco and alcohol have been around for ages, but new temptations and spinoffs are being marketed all the time: meth, painkillers, energy drinks, you name it.

  • Substance Abuse, Schizophrenia And Risk Of Violence
    Aug 17, 2009 | Full text

    Importantly, the study also finds that the risk of violence from patients with psychoses who also have substance use disorder is no greater than those who have a substance use disorder but who do not have a psychotic illness – in other words, schizophrenia and other psychotic illnesses do not appear to be responsible for any additional risk of violence above the increased risk associated with substance abuse.

  • Marijuana Linked to Aggressive Testicular Cancer
    Feb 16, 2009 | Full text

    Smoking marijuana over an extended period of time appears to greatly boost a young man’s risk for developing a particularly aggressive form of testicular cancer, a new study reveals. [...]

Psychoactive Substances »

  • Prescription Pain Relievers
    Oct 22, 2008 | Full text

    Relief from pain. In some people, prescription pain relievers also cause euphoria or feelings of well being by affecting the brain regions that mediate pleasure. This is why they are abused. Other effects include drowsiness, constipation and slowed breathing. [...]

  • Study shows Ritalin may cause long-term changes in the brain
    Oct 21, 2008 | Full text

    On Sunday researchers at the University of Buffalo reported that Ritalin, used on children diagnosed with ADHD, may cause long-term changes in the brain. Many clinicians regard Ritalin as short-acting but the research with gene expression in an animal model suggests that it has the potential for causing long-lasting changes [...]

  • Brain Receptors for Marijuana/Cannabis
    Oct 20, 2008 | Full text

    The body produces many chemicals and hormones, i.e., histamines, steroids, thyroid hormone, digitalis-like substances, adrenalin, etc, all of which work by attaching to corresponding brain receptors. The key is that these natural substances produced by the body are present in nanogram amounts [...]

Cultural Environment »

  • Time for a Sales Tax on Sinsemilla?
    Mar 16, 2009 | Full text

    As California State Assembly member Tom Ammiano put it: “What if California could raise hundreds of millions of dollars in new revenue to preserve vital state services without any tax increase?” [...]

  • Stop The Afghan Drug Trade, Stop Terrorism
    Mar 1, 2009 | Full text

    “The fight against drugs is actually the fight for Afghanistan,” said Afghan President Hamid Karzai when he took office in 2002. Judging by the current situation, Afghanistan is losing. [...]

  • Conventional wisdom strikes out
    Oct 6, 2008 | Full text

    Among the things everybody knows is that Democrats, being the party of the little people, raise money in small contributions, whereas Republicans, being the party of fat cats, raise funds in huge basketfuls from wealthy corporate types. At least, that’s the way the world is usually portrayed by the “Today Show,” The New York Times and the Democratic Party. So it’s of more than passing interest to see [...]